![]() ![]() Maybe it's better to walk away from "A Perfect Day for Bananafish" with an emotional or spiritual reaction, rather than an analytical one. And this is certainly a legitimate approach to the text. If you buy into this theory, you might very well take issue with all the "deep hidden meaning" conclusions that critics have drawn and that we've explored in "Symbols, Imagery, Allegory." You might think that it's the wrong approach to assign any one meaning to each of the metaphors and images in this text (like the bananafish, the color blue, the nail polish). While Eastern philosophy isnt explicitly discussed in 'Bananafish,' its easy to see a spiritual theme reflected in. Perhaps we're meant to meditate on this and the other stories in the collection, but we're not meant to "figure out" what the "answer" is. This is the epigraph to Nine Stories, the 1953 collection that opens with 'A Perfect Day for Bananafish.' Together, these nine stories explore themes of innocence, youth, the psychological effects of war, and Eastern philosophy. There may be an answer to his question, but it's not one that anyone could write down or explain in a thesis paper. And, of course, the big question in "Bananafish" is…why does Seymour kill himself? It's very possible that Salinger intends his story as a sort of kōan in itself. This epigraph reminds us that some questions – actually, the most important questions, spiritually speaking – don't have logical answers. The epigraph provides the author with an opportunity to give us a hint (or sometimes tell us directly) how to interpret his writing. What does this have to do with "A Perfect Day for Bananafish"? Remember that the point of an epigraph is to inform the way we read a work. In other words, you can't Google the answer to this one. But it's not a logical answer that you could explain to someone else. What is the sound of one hand clapping? If you meditate on this long enough, claim the Zen Buddhists, you will come up with an answer. If we ask you, "What is the square root of 435?" you can solve the problem using the usual parts of your brain (or a handy calculator). But the answer to the riddle isn't logical. ![]() A kōan is a sort of riddle, as you can see from this particular example. Knowledge is pointless, she says, unless it ultimately leads to wisdom. Their goal is to amass as much of it as quickly as possible, which Franny finds no more noble than trying to amass wealth, fame, or any material good. Similarly, in Salinger's novel Franny and Zooey, college student Franny Glass (Seymour's younger sister) complains that in school, they learn nothing but this useless knowledge. To get at those, you have to "empty yourself" of all logical truths. His theory is that we are all so distracted and filled up with the useless things we learn in school – like math and science and grammar and logic – that we don't open ourselves to real spiritual truths. These two works book-end Nine Stories, literally and thematically, and "Teddy" really informs the way that we read and interpret "Bananafish." In "Teddy," for example, the titular character, an enlightened young man and spiritual prodigy, explains to a college student the way that knowledge works. If this stuff interests you, we'd recommend reading "Bananafish" and "Teddy" (the final piece in the Nine Stories collection) together. While Eastern philosophy isn't explicitly discussed in "Bananafish," it's easy to see a spiritual theme reflected in the story. But what is the sound of one hand clapping? – A Zen Kōan This is the epigraph to Nine Stories, the 1953 collection that opens with "A Perfect Day for Bananafish." Together, these nine stories explore themes of innocence, youth, the psychological effects of war, and Eastern philosophy. Wiki doesn't mention anything and Googling "ballerina" and "clothes" just brings up sites for costumes and dance outfits (not helped by the fact there's a clothing/baby goods designer called Banana Fish).We know the sound of two hands clapping. It sounds like it could be a type of skirt or blouse, or possibly a scarf, but I have no idea. The mother then changes topics and it's never mentioned again. The daughter is in Florida with her husband who's recently come back from the war in Europe, while the mother is in New York and is worried the husband is dangerously unstable.Īt one point they start talking about fashions and the clothes the daughter has brought with her, and have the following exchange:ĭaughter: "It's too long. The first half is a phone conversation between a daughter and mother. Salinger's short story "A Perfect Day for Bananafish" (pdf link) into Japanese. ![]() My wife is taking a translation class, and the continuing class project is to translate J.D. But I've encountered another usage of the word that has me stumped. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |